Best Bolt & Screw Extractors 2019 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

a bolt & screw extractor

Extracting a broken bolt or screw requires you to put your brain cells to use. Since the operation is so delicate and complex, it requires the best quality tools, so as not to worsen the situation. Finding these tools can be daunting, even for the most knowledgeable handyman. We’ve compiled reviews of the best bolt and screw extractor tools, to help you identify which one will do the job with the most ease and efficiency.

A Breakdown of our Top Picks

ModelPriceEditor Rating
The Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 Screw & Bolt Extractor Set
The Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 Screw & Bolt Extractor Set(Top Pick)

Check Price
4.75/5
The IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001
The IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001(Best for the Money)

Check Price
4.60/5
TACKLIFE 18pcs Broken Bolt & Screw Extractor
TACKLIFE 18pcs Broken Bolt & Screw Extractor

Check Price
4.35/5
Vampliers Screw Extraction Pliers
Vampliers Screw Extraction Pliers

Check Price
4.30/5
Bosch BPSPE6D 12 Piece Steel Spiral Flute Screw Extractor Set
Bosch BPSPE6D 12 Piece Steel Spiral Flute Screw Extractor Set

Check Price
4.15/5

8 Best Screw and Bolt Extractors – Reviews 2019

1. The Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 Screw & Bolt Extractor Set – Top Pick

Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 Screw & Bolt Extractor Set

The 25-piece Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 extractor set comes in a hard durable case, which makes transporting the tools much easier and more convenient.

The set includes various extractors of different sizes and shapes to get the job done without the need for additional tools. The versatility of this set is what makes it the best easy-out bolt extractor set. Users have described it as a lifesaver.

The extractors are made of hard durable material, so they won’t snap or break during extraction, and their easy-out design makes them very user-friendly.

With this set, you should expect outstanding results. However, these tools rust very quickly, so make sure to keep them in the case when they’re not being used.

Pros
  • Durable case
  • Versatile
  • Easy to use
  • High performance
  • Good quality
Cons
  • Rusts quickly

2. The IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001 – Best for the Money

The IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001

It comes as no surprise that the second item on the list is also of the IRWIN family, because this company is renowned for manufacturing some of the best tools out there. The IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001 set comes in a case for convenience and better transporting. The set includes five common extractor sizes to remove bolts that are painted over, rounded off, or rusted.

The reverse spiral extractors are designed to maximize gripping power to extract bolts from tough conditions. The tools are made of carbon steel to make them durable and increase their lifespan; this means you won’t have to replace your set regularly.

The extractors are designed to be versatile, in order to work with any type of fastener. The set also comes with other accessories, such as adjustable wrenches and vises.

With so many benefits, you’d expect it to be expensive, yet that’s not the case. This set is indeed the best for the money, because of its affordable price.

On the downside, some of the extractors cause the fasteners to become rounded instead of extracting them.

Pros
  • Durable case
  • Easy to transport
  • Extractors have maximum gripping power
  • Durable
  • Versatile
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Causes fasteners to be rounded

3. TACKLIFE 18pcs Broken Bolt & Screw Extractor

TACKLIFE 18pcs Broken Bolt & Screw Extractor

With the TACKLIFE 18pcs Broken Bolt & Screw Extractor set, you have the luxury of picking from a wide variety of extractors, and they all come in an aesthetic case. The tools are neatly fitted in the case to prevent them from bouncing around during transport.

What we love about this set is the simplicity of all its tools. They’re easy to use, yet very efficient. There are bits and extractors of various sizes, making the set very versatile. The tools are also very durable, so it will be a while before the need to replace the set arises.

A negative aspect of this set is that the reamers do not work as efficiently as the extractors.

Pros
  • Aesthetic case
  • Durable tools
  • Simple to use
  • Efficient
  • Versatile
Cons
  • Reamers don’t work properly

4. Vampliers Screw Extraction Pliers

Vampliers Screw Extraction Pliers

The Vampliers Screw Extraction Pliers are made of high-quality carbon steel, making them very durable and heavy-duty. The concave jaw design allows you to grip almost any screw with little to no effort, regardless of the screw’s condition.

These pliers have an ergonomic elastomer handle design that provides more comfort to the user and better and stronger gripping. The tool is efficient and a true lifesaver when it comes to extracting stubborn screws.

A problem with these pliers is that the jaws begin to wear out fairly fast, thus rendering the tool useless.

Pros
  • High quality
  • Durable material
  • Works efficiently
  • Ergonomic
Cons
  • Jaws wear out quickly

5. Bosch BPSPE6D 12 Piece Steel Spiral Flute Screw Extractor Set

Bosch BPSPE6D 12 Piece Steel Spiral Flute Screw Extractor Set

The Bosch BPSPE6D set includes screw extractors to remove stripped screws, bolts, and fasteners easily, and flutes to have a firm grip on the metal. The case in which the set is packed is hard and compact.

The tools are made of heat-treated carbon steel for superior durability. Extracting bits with these tools will seem like a walk in the park, because they’re so efficient.

However, you have to be very careful when working with a really stubborn fastener, as you might end up breaking the tool. Another issue is that the drill bits do not drill fully into the fastener.

Pros
  • Versatile
  • Durable tools
  • Compact case
Cons
  • Tools might break with excessive pressure
  • Drill bits do not drill fully into fastener

6. ARES 70016| Stripped Screw & Bolt Extractor Tool

ARES 70016| Stripped Screw & Bolt Extractor Tool

The universal design of the ARES 70016 extractor tool allows you to extract damaged studs of various sizes, thus making it a versatile tool.

To add to its versatility, the drive can be used with hand ratchets, air ratchets, and impact wrenches. The hexagonal flat can be used with locking pliers, flat wrenches, adjustable wrenches, and sockets.

It’s made of high-grade, heat-treated alloy steel for durability, and it’s been coated with chrome to prevent rusting. This tool can access small areas, because of its compact design.

Users have noticed that this tool does not extract 6mm studs. It works better in conjunction with heat and penetrating oil.

Pros
  • Versatile
  • Durable
  • Rust-resistant
Cons
  • Does not extract small studs
  • Needs heat and penetrating oil to improve efficiency

7. Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set

Neiko 04204A Hex Head Multi-Spline Screw and Bolt Extractor Set

The Neiko 04204A screw and bolt extractor set comes with a variety of tools. The case appears to be durable and the tools are neatly packed inside. The set is versatile, as it has a variety of extractor tools.

However, the issues begin to surface as soon as you start using the tools. They get stuck, break easily, and do not perform the task. The tools are mediocre quality and not at all durable.

Pros
  • Durable case
  • Versatile
Cons
  • Tools are inadequate
  • Break easily
  • Get stuck

8. Ontel SpeedOut Damaged Screw Extractor & Bolt Extractor Set

Ontel SpeedOut Damaged Screw Extractor & Bolt Extractor Set

The first thing you notice about the Ontel SpeedOut extractor set is how well the tools are packed in the compact case. The set isn’t very versatile, as it only features four tools.

The tools are made of 100% carbon steel, so they should be durable. However, consumers have complained about the tools breaking on the first use. The tools are mediocre, as they fail to perform even on the smallest tasks. They aren’t durable at all, despite the product description stating otherwise.

Consumers have gone as far as describing this set as a complete waste of money; we therefore do not recommend it to anyone.

Pros
  • Compact case
Cons
  • Not durable
  • Breaks easily
  • Performs inadequately

Buyer’s Guide

To make a sound decision on what extractor tool set to purchase, be aware of the tools used in the extracting process. The following are the most commonly used ones.

Bolt and Stud Extractor Tool: This tool can be used on most drills and drives. It comes in either cone shape or cylindrical shape. To use it, attach one end to the drill and push the other end on your drive.

Extraction Pliers: These are used when the screw or bolt is sticking out but won’t come out further. You clamp them on the fastener, make sure you’ve got a good grip, and pull on it.

Bolt Extractor: The inside of the bolt extractor is round, which makes it the ideal tool to remove bolts with rounded heads.

Spiral Screw Extractor: This looks similar to a drill bit. To use it, attach it to a power drill and begin drilling to create a hole through the fastener.

Conclusion

The Irwin Tools Hanson 53227 Screw & Bolt Extractor Set is our top recommended extractor set, as it stands out among the tools mentioned above. However, the IRWIN HANSON BOLT-GRIP 394001 is the best set for the money, ideal for those who prefer to keep track of their budget. Hopefully, these reviews and buyer’s guide will help you identify the toolset that will enable you to take on the challenging task of extracting fasteners with much more confidence.

About the Author Adam Harris

Hi there! My name is Adam and I write for HealthyHandyman. I have a great passion for writing about everything related to tools, home improvement, and DIY. In my spare time, I'm either fishing, playing the guitar, or spending quality time with my beloved wife. You'll also often find me in my workshop working on some new project!