Healthyhandyman is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Best Paint Roller Covers 2020 – Reviews & Comparisons

grand flourish 6Piece for Important Paint Works High Density Premium Polyester Paint Roller Covers 9 inch

Even though paint roller covers are not the most exciting tool in the world, they serve an important role, which is why we take them quite seriously.

We’ve assembled a list of the five top choices of paint roller covers on the market. These units have been vetted based on overall performance and quality, as well as the level of value they provide for the user.

There are products here for buyers of every budget, so read on for paint roller cover reviews!

Comparison (updated in 2020)

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Bates 9″ Covers Bates 9″ Covers
  • 5 pack
  • Tightly wound fibers prevent shedding
  • Can be used with virtually any material
  • Second place
    Pro Grade Microfiber Covers Pro Grade Microfiber Covers
  • Great value
  • Robust life expectancy
  • Can work with any paint or primer
  • Third place
    Grand Flourish Covers Grand Flourish Covers
  • Affordable
  • Can be used with any paint
  • Designed to apply rich coats
  • Wooster Brush Lambswool 100 Cover Wooster Brush Lambswool 100 Cover
  • Very durable
  • Extremely thick
  • Optimized for harsh solvents
  • FoamPRO 91 9″ Surface Cover FoamPRO 91 9″ Surface Cover
  • Very affordable
  • Simplest product
  • Can be used with any paint or solvent
  • The 5 Best Paint Roller Covers

    1. Bates 9″ Paint Roller Covers (5-Pack) – Best Overall

    Bates- Paint Roller Covers

    This five-pack seems simple enough, but it includes a few key features that serious-minded buyers won’t want to pass up. The covers’ microfibers are tightly woven to maximize overall durability.

    This feature also prevents shedding, which can improve quality of work. The high-density build makes the covers easier to reuse and clean, thus extending their life expectancy.

    As a bonus, you can use Bates paint roller covers with any type of paint, primer, or stain.

    These are more expensive than most paint covers. The good news is that even the priciest of paint covers probably won’t break most budgets. Still, if you’re looking for a bargain, this might not be it.

    • Five pack
    • Tightly wound fibers prevent shedding
    • Can be used with virtually any material
    • Pricey relative to the wider world of paint roller covers

    2. Pro Grade Microfiber Paint Roller Covers (6-Pack)Pro Grade

    This six-pack is a great value for buyers who want a bit more bang for their buck. Although the price is cheaper than Bates, the ultimate level of quality is similar.

    It’s easy to clean, can be used with virtually any paint and primer, and tends to enjoy a fairly robust life expectancy. Unfortunately, the fibers do tend to shed easily. This may lead to problems with the final quality of your work, which is something to look out for.

    Still, if you are looking for a product that maximizes the value factor, this is a good option to consider.

    • Great value opportunity
    • Can work with any paint or primer
    • Robust life expectancy
    • Tends to shed easily, which may compromise the quality of your work

    3. Grand Flourish Paint Roller Covers (6-Pack)

    grand flourish

    Next up is another six-pack. The Grand Flourish high-density polyester paint roller cover is designed to hold a large amount of paint. The thought behind this feature is that it allows you to apply rich coats to your workpiece.

    The covers can be used with any paint and applied to any surfaces, as long as they’re smooth. It’s a good product for budget-minded shoppers, but it does have limitations. For one thing, life expectancy is fairly limited.

    The weaving of the fabric is not so substantial that it can withstand a significant number of uses. However, for some users, the value element will override durability concerns.

    • Affordable
    • Designed to apply rich coats
    • Not very durable

    4. Wooster Brush Lambswool 100 Roller Cover

    Wooster Brush

    This lambswool roller cover is actually the most expensive product on our list, as it does not come in a multi-pack. However, if you have some leeway in your budget, you may find that worthwhile to invest in the Wooster.

    This is an extremely thick and dense product that is specially optimized for scenarios in which harsh solvents are being used. Chemicals that may spell doom for the average paint roller cover won’t have a substantial impact on this unit.

    The price factor is restrictive, but if you need the enhanced durability, it may be money well spent.

    • Very durable
    • Quite pricey

    5. FoamPRO 91 9″ Surface Roller Cover (3-Pack)


    Last, we look at the simplest product on our list. The FoamPro is optimal for buyers who want the most affordable product.

    These foam coverings can be used with any paint or solvent. Just don’t expect them to stick around for very long. These covers are difficult to clean, which can be a big pain. They also shed substantially, and the overall life expectancy tends to be very short as a result.

    If you need a quick product for a one-time project, this might be the option to reach for. However, if you have multiple painting jobs to do, it may not be right for you.

    • Very affordable
    • Not very durable
    • Tends to be quite difficult to wash
    • Sheds a lot

    Buyer’s Guide

    Now you know your options, but perhaps you haven’t made up your mind yet. The considerations below are designed to help make your decision easier.


    The number of covers featured in a pack is what determines the ultimate value offering of your purchase. Typically, the more covers you can get at once, the better price per unit.

    Of course, it’s only worthwhile to do this if you are buying a product that you will actually make use of, so choose wisely!

    Fiber Quality

    It’s important to get something that is well built. As you may have noticed from our list, cheaper units tend to shed. When a roller sheds substantially, it leaves behind a ton of residue on your workpiece, which can compromise the overall quality.
    Unfortunately, it is hard to know the overall quality of a product’s build without testing it first. The best way is either to talk with people who have used the cover in the past or to read handy reviews, like this list!

    Did you know? That electric paint rollers can get the job done quicker? See our 5 top picks here.


    Most paint roller covers can be used with any material. However, there are certain exceptions. Cheaper units often struggle with solvents and other harsh chemicals. While many products will be well-equipped for performing most tasks, users with specialized needs should double-check the product’s limitations before finalizing a buy.


    You really shouldn’t break the bank on a paint roller cover. This is a fairly affordable piece of equipment that even buyers on a budget can work with.

    The low price tag allows you to splurge a little bit, going with a higher-end product than perhaps you would usually opt for.

    This is especially important if you are working with heavy-duty solvents. For example, some of the pricier selections we examined justified their price tag by being hyper durable and compatible with any material. Of course, you will have to decide for yourself what features are worth paying big bucks for.


    Now it is time to make a final decision. If you want something that maximizes the quality factor, take a second look at our top pick, the Bates 9″ Paint Roller Covers.

    You can also get a great choice at an affordable price with our runner-up, the Pro Grade Microfiber Paint Roller Covers. This is a value-driven six-pack that gives you tons of bang for your buck!

    Of course, all five options on our list are great, so you shouldn’t have any trouble buying paint covers with confidence!

    Featured image credit: Amazon

    Related posts

    Other categories

    Project ideas

    Hand & power tools