Most of us would rather never have to think about sewage, or how it’s transported out of the home. If you’ve ever had your sewage pump fail, you’re all too aware that the consequences of neglect can be catastrophic. The last thing you’d ever hope for is a backup of wastewater in your home!
When it’s time to replace your sewage pump, you’ll want to make an educated decision that you can trust won’t leave you in panic mode with a failed pump and an awful mess. To help you, we’ve researched and tested the top sewage pumps on the market to determine how they measure up. Important features like flow rate, durability, and efficiency were put to the test.
We’ve compared warranties, capabilities, and affordability to make sure these reviews will help you find the best sewage ejector pump for your needs.
|Liberty Pumps LE51A|
|Zoeller 267-0001 M267|
|Acquaer 1/2 HP||2 Years||4.35/5|
|Hallmark Industries MA0387X-9||1 Year||4.30/5|
Commercial-grade durability for residential homes is the theme of the Liberty Pumps LE51A. This efficient motor manages to produce a flow rate of 160 GPM on just 0.5 horsepower, making it very efficient. This efficiency helps translate to reduced energy costs and longer life expectancy. Further aiding in lengthening the lifespan of this pump are the permanently lubricated bearings and oil-filled, thermally protected motor. Add a shut-off head of 25 feet and the ability to handle two-inch solids, and it’s clear that this is one of the best sewage grinder pumps available.
The power cord features a quick-disconnect design that allows you to replace it in seconds without breaking the motor seals. Even better, this pump also offers manual operation in the event of a switch failure or any other issue. All that said, there are two things that hold this pump back. First, it’s at the higher end of the price range, though it does provide longevity and features to match. Second, some of these pumps seem to have been shipped with faulty gaskets from the factory that don’t properly seal. Thankfully, the two-year warranty covers any such experiences.
Constructed from cast iron and thermoplastic, this sewage pump from WaterAce is built durable for a long life. Although it’s not a grinder pump, it is able to move two-inch solids like our number one pick, but a flow rate of only 95 GPM holds it back. In its defense, this pump is at a much lower price point, which is why it makes our pick for best sewage pump for the money.
When it comes to installation, this pump is quick and easy. A 20-foot power cord is attached to a 3-prong plug that connects to a standard 110V outlet. If anything will go wrong with this pump, it would be the float ball getting stuck. A minor fix that’s covered under the two-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Zoeller makes a great pump that is worth considering if you want a premium product and don’t mind the accompanying expense. Built in the USA and equipped with a three-year warranty, each pump is 100% factory tested before being shipped out for distribution. Zoeller stands behind the Waste-Mate sewage pump, and it continues to deliver reliable performance year after year. Although uncommon, this pump has occasionally failed within the first year. Zoeller honors their warranty and a full replacement can be expected on the off chance that this happens to you.
At ½ HP this pump produces a flow rate of 128 GPM, and a 21.5-foot shut-off head. With a non-clogging vortex impeller made from cast iron, this grinder pump can pass two-inch solids with ease. The fully submersible cast iron housing is watertight and dust-tight to ensure no external damage occurs.
At only 80 GPM of water flow, this 0.5-horsepower pump isn’t the most powerful on our list. It is able to pass two-inch solids but does not feature grinding capabilities. With a maximum head of 27 feet, this pump definitely creates a respectable vertical lift. Combine that with the affordable price and it easily makes its way onto our top 10 list.
With a cast iron volute built durable to protect the pump for long-life operation, Acquaer shows confidence in their product by backing it up with a two-year warranty. Installation is simple with a 10-foot power cord plugging into standard 115V electric. It is recommended to test the float switch before installing. The first one came with a faulty switch which wasn’t noticed until after installation. Besides this, pumps have also been known to arrive DOA for other reasons. Luckily, Acquaer was good about sending out a replacement pump quickly since it’s covered by their warranty.
Showing a stout power rating of 1.0 horsepower, the MA0387X-9 from Hallmark Industries is a powerful pump. With a flow rating measuring just over 120 GPM, this pump moves a lot of water, though not quite as much as some of its less powerful competitors ranked higher on this list. This means it’s not as efficient either, even though it does move respectable volumes of water. Where it really shines is the 49’ lift capabilities it boasts.
This submersible pump contains a hermetically sealed motor with thermal protection, helping prevent overheating to ensure a long service life. The cast iron impeller makes this grinder pump able to crush serious solids and the two-inch discharge will have no problem evacuating them. On the downside, only a one-year parts warranty is included. Also, a 220V outlet will be required. The float switch also has problems getting stuck and running continuously. A great pump overall, it’s held back by several small issues.
Topping out at 166 GPM of water flow, the ½ HP SEL50 sewage pump puts up very respectable numbers. At 20 feet of lift it still manages a flow rate of 33 GPM. It can handle the standard two-inch solids with ease, though it doesn’t offer waste grinding capabilities. It is built for automatic operation, but it does have manual operation abilities should you happen to need them.
This pump comes with a standard one-year warranty, a necessity since it’s known to sometimes fail within just a few months. If you have the option to purchase an extra warranty, do so. For the price, more reliable pumps can be found that also offer more features.
Superior pump offers an affordable alternative with some worthwhile features. The cast aluminum, non-clogging vortex impeller will easily handle two-inch solids. The split-capacitor motor is thermally protected and built for continuous duty. At 0.5 horsepower, it offers 80 GPM of water flow. While better than some models on the market, it’s one of the less powerful options on our reviews list. It is capable of pumping water to a height of 25 feet maximum.
Regrettably, this pump often dies before the three-year mark. After discovering flooding, it was determined that the float switch was no good. Sadly, the float switch turns out to be a common weak link with this model. In this case, it was within the one-year warranty time frame. While the warranty covered it this time, it won’t cover the cost to repair the damage caused by flooding. It also wouldn’t cover it if this had happened a few months further down the line. Though priced quite affordably, the 93501 sewage pump may not be the best long term investment.
Offering a 103 GPM flow rate from a 0.5-horsepower pump, the Wayne RPP50 offers better performance than many of its competitors. It’s constructed from durable cast iron and is able to pass the standard two-inch solids with no problems. Since it features a piggy-back tether float switch, you have the option to enable manual operation should you need it. While this pump can replace most existing sewage pumps without a change in plumbing, it’s only designed for sewer basins with a diameter of 18” or greater.
The one-year warranty will protect you from factory defects, though not much else. You may be glad for the limited warranty though if you do happen to get one of the semi-common problems that manage to sneak through quality control. Seals leaking oil, severed wires, and float switch failure aren’t commonplace, but they’re not exactly rarities.
ECO-FLO Products offers an economically priced automatic sewage pump. It can handle 2” waste solids with no problems, but it does not have a grinding function to handle other solids. This submersible pump is advertised as having a 20-foot long power cord, a feature that may be a selling point if your situation requires the extra length. To our dismay, the shipped unit was only equipped with a 10-foot power cable. If you purchase this pump expecting it to cover a distance over 10 feet, you’ll be very unpleasantly surprised. The low price mirrors the lower-end quality, and this pump should only be expected to survive a few years of hard use.
With a powerful 0.75-horsepower motor, this BURCAM sewage grinder pump should have one of the best flow rates on this list. On the contrary, it has a dismal flow rate of only 70 GPM maximum, far less than lower-powered competitors. This also means it’s an inefficient design that won’t save you on your energy bill. This poor performance is disappointing from a product with such a high cost. Constructed from stainless steel, this unit is rugged and is unlikely to be damaged externally. The biggest draw to this pump is its grinder type impeller of cast iron, which allows it to make quick work of solids. That said, don’t expect it to handle trash and sanitary pads, as it may cause lasting damage. While the grinder makes this a very capable pump, it’s also noticeably louder. A two-year warranty is standard.
When purchasing a new sewage pump, the most important question is how much waste can it move? The pump motor is rated in horsepower or HP. While this measures the power of the motor, it’s not a direct indication of how much water the pump is actually moving. The water flow is instead measured in GPM, which stands for gallons per minute. Remember to look for the flow rate instead of the HP, since a motor can be high in horsepower but still have only mediocre flow rates.
When the HP is high but the flow rate is not, that means the motor is not running efficiently. Conversely, a motor that creates high flow rates with lower horsepower is considered high-efficiency. The more efficiently a motor can perform, the lower its impact on your energy consumption, saving you money in the long term.
Most sewage pumps are designed to operate off of a standard outlet. However, some are designed to run off of 230V instead. If you currently have a 230V pump installed, you will need to replace it with another 230V pump. Similarly, if you only have hookups for standard 110V electric, then you’ll need to make sure that you don’t get one designed for 230V.
Ten feet is about the standard length for a majority of sewage pumps. For many applications, this length will be sufficient. In cases where a longer power supply is required, look for one of the pumps that is equipped with a 20-foot power cord instead. Our pick for best overall value, the WaterAce WA50RSWW in second place, includes a 20-foot power cable for a very affordable price. If you need the extra length to reach a power source, it’s the pump we’d recommend.
In all likelihood, you’d rather not think about sewage pumps again for quite some time once your new one is installed! If you get a robust and reliable model like our top pick from Liberty Pumps, then you shouldn’t have to give it a thought anytime soon.
If you want more proof of reliability for the pump you choose, then look at the included warranty. A longer-term warranty shows that the manufacturer stands behind their product and believes in it. A short-term warranty of one year or less shows that the maker isn’t confident in their offering. A good warranty is similar to insurance, you don’t expect something to go wrong, but you’re covered in case it does.
All of these pumps can easily pass two-inch solids. However, some do a much better job of it than others by employing impellers made of metal that can easily grind up waste for transportation. These models are much less likely to get clogged up. You still won’t want to test them with sanitary pads though!
Your sewage pump is a long-term investment. Spending more now might buy some peace of mind, as well as saving you money overall down the line. That being said, spending more doesn’t necessarily mean you’re guaranteed a better product. You should look for which pump offers the greatest amount of features that you want for the most reasonable price.
Equipped with the information presented in our top ten reviews list and buyer’s guide, you are now prepared to make a well-educated purchase. Our top pick was the Liberty Pumps LE51A. With an incredible flow rate of 160 GPM from a motor pushing just ½ HP, this pump is powerful and efficient. Once you consider the long lifespan and two-year warranty, it’s easy to see how it earned our top position.
For best overall value, we feel the WaterAce WA50RSWW earns our second spot on the list. The affordable price puts in the budget of every homeowner, with a two-year warranty included to protect your investment. The 20-foot power cord plugs into a standard outlet, making installation simple and painless. When budget is of no concern though, the Zoeller M267 Waste-Mate is our pick for premium choice, earning it the third position on our list. Although priced very high, the lifespan matches the price. A three-year warranty backs it up and each unit is 100% factory tested to protect against DOA units. No matter which model you choose, you’re sure to be satisfied with your decision as your new pump hopefully stays out of sight and out of mind.
Featured image credit: Sewage pumps by Matt Brown licensed by CC 2.0
Hi there! My name is Adam and I write for HealthyHandyman. I have a great passion for writing about everything related to tools, home improvement, and DIY. In my spare time, I'm either fishing, playing the guitar, or spending quality time with my beloved wife. You'll also often find me in my workshop working on some new project!
Best Air Compressors For Pneumatic Tools 2019 – Reviews & Top Picks
Best Portable Air Compressor For Car Tires 2019- Reviews & Top Picks
Best Air Compressor for Your Home Garages 2019 — Reviews & Top Picks
Best Budget Impact Wrench Under $100 – Reviews & Guide