Best Sump Pumps 2019 – Top Picks & Reviews

Last Updated:

sump pump in actionBuying a sump pump takes a little bit of research. Not all sump pumps are the same and with such an important purchase, it’s useful to know exactly what you’re getting for your money. For this reason, we’ve created a list of sump pump reviews which are up-to-date for 2019. These should help you narrow down the various options. If you’re still undecided after the reviews, check out the Buying Guide for further tips. Let’s take a look at the best sump pumps of 2019!

Comparison of our Favorite Products

ModelPriceTypeEditor Rating
(Top Pick)

Check Price
Superior Pump 91250
Superior Pump 91250

(Best for the Money)

Check Price
Wayne ESP25
Wayne ESP25

Check Price
Battery backup4.5./5
Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible
Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate

Check Price
Superior Pump 92341
Superior Pump 92341

Check Price

5 Best Sump Pumps – Reviews 2019:

1. WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Sump Pump – Top Pick

WAYNE CDU980E HPCapable of moving up to 4600 gallons per hour, the Wayne CDU980E is, without a doubt, the best sump pump for your basement. Debris is filtered while clogging is minimized thanks to the top suction design. What makes it the best submersible sump pump on the market is its high-quality design.

The motor is made of stainless steel and is corrosion-resistant while the pump base is made of cast iron. A stainless steel handle at the top makes the sump pump much more portable. However, the handle is a little on the small side. Therefore it’s a very rugged product capable of withstanding high water pressure and any possible collisions with objects. It’s designed for sump pits that are at least 11 inches in diameter and is fully submersible as the name suggests.

What is particularly good about this unit is the 2HP motor which makes it particularly good value for money. The sump pump’s switch is highly responsive and has a well-designed guard which protects it from damage when moved. Finally, the power cord is fully submersible though it is on the short side. Minor the short cable and small handle, this sump pump is very much the best of the best and should do a great job when required.


  • Up to 4600 gallons per hour
  • High-quality materials
  • Excellent switch
  • Handle small and cable short

2. Superior Pump 91250 – Best Sump Pump for the Money

Superior Pump 91250This is a 1/4 HP submersible utility pump that offers excellent power, particularly for the price. Capable of pumping up to 30 gallons per minute and 25 vertical feet upwards, it has a small yet durable thermoplastic frame which helps avoid corrosion. One of this pump’s best features is its continuous usage. It can run a long time without issue.

Because it’s a utility pump, it’s versatile. The 91250 can be used anytime, anywhere. While usually operated manually, the unit does have a switch which can automatically turn off the pump. If you’re looking for a consistent and reliable product, this is for you. It’s particularly good for draining still water from swimming pools and fountains, as well as dealing with the problems of flooded basements.

The unit is fully submersible and has a 10-foot power cord which is water-resistant and of tough construction. However, it has been said by some consumers that the cord is not flexible enough which may be an issue when trying to reach a power outlet. The continuous-duty motor offers excellent, consistent performance. What’s more, it’s very quiet when in operation. Another small disadvantage of this sump pump is that it lacks a float switch meaning that it cannot be used as a sump pump unless one is added. Despite this, it’s the best sump pump for the money.


  • Solid performance
  • Quiet operation
  • Versatile
  • Cord lacks flexibility
  • No float switch

3. Wayne ESP25 Battery Backup Sump Pump

Wayne ESP25What happens if your primary sump pump fails you when you need it most? If you have the Wayne ESP25 then there’s no need to worry about such a possibility. The best battery backup sump pump, it’s made for emergencies such as when there’s a power outage. The 1/3 HP sump pump runs off a 12VDC power source.

Completely standalone, it can be a backup for any sump pump. The Wayne ESP25 has its own float switch so there’s no need to connect it in any way to your existing sump pump. It’s as easy as installing it alongside your existing sump pump and it’s good to go. The thermoplastic housing of this unit is nice and durable. What’s more, it’s completely waterproof.

Further advantages include its quiet operation and the fact that it’s easy to install. A couple of downsides include the battery cable and charger cord being on the short side as well as there not being an alarm reset button. However, the alarm doesn’t sound for long and it’s not particularly loud. This in itself could be problematic, particularly if you’re unable to hear when it starts. Able to pump 2,300 gallons of water per hour, it can provide peace of mind when your primary sump pump malfunctions or during a power outage and is a sensible choice.


  • Quite powerful
  • On the quiet side
  • No alarm reset
  • Cables are short

4. Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump

Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate SubmersibleBig and green, the Zoeller M53 probably won’t win any awards for its appearance. But when it’s going into a sump pit in your basement, does it really matter? Made from cast iron housing on top of a thermoplastic base, it’s a durable product. There’s no doubt that this is The Hulk of sump pumps not just because of its size and color but also because it weighs a hefty 21 lbs.

One of the main advantages of this submersible sump pump is that even with heavy usage, it should continue running as good as new. Aside from durability, the M53 Mighty-Mate is highly efficient and can manage 45 gallons of water per minute and 2700 gallons per hour. Whether clearing water from a sump pit or from a pool in anticipation of cleaning, it’s a great choice. You might think from looking at the bulky design that this sump pump is noisy but it’s surprisingly quiet.

Some basic maintenance of this pump is required on occasion such as clearing the flow holes as debris accumulates but this is fairly normal for sump pumps. One criticism that can be leveled at this product is that the float switch is on the weak side and is quite high up meaning that small water jobs are pretty much out of the question.


  • Very durable
  • Good power
  • Weak switch
  • Not great for small water jobs

5. Superior Pump 92341 Sump Pump

Superior Pump 92341With the pump housing and base of cast iron construction, the Superior Pump 92341 is built to last. Meanwhile, other parts of this sump pump such as the handle are made of stainless steel. This is a versatile 1/3 hp submersible sump pump that has an automatic on/off vertical float switch that can be easily removed. This means that this unit can also be used as a utility pump making it particularly versatile.

Capable of moving up to 46 gallons of water per minute or 2760 gallons per hour, it’s powerful yet it’s also energy efficient at 4.1 amp with a thermally protected motor. This is intended to provide the Superior Pump 92341 with longer life. For a sump pump, this unit has a fairly sleek design and fits well in narrow sump basins. Despite its sturdy build, it’s surprisingly quiet.

Despite several clear advantages, it does have its flaws. One of the main concerns is about this product’s durability. Despite the seemingly solid construction, some consumers have complained about rusted parts as well as the unit failing altogether. Therefore, it comes down to whether you are willing to risk such a thing based on the low price. Overall we think it’s a solid budget option.


  • Can also be used as a utility pump
  • Fits inside narrow sump basins
  • Some complaints of rusted parts

Buying Guide

We know what a sump pump is, what it does, and what some of the best sump pumps on the market are. Now it’s time to decide which type of sump pump you need for your home.

Pump Type

There are two types of sump pumps to consider: pedestal and submersible and each have its own unique advantages as well as a few disadvantages.


a submersible pumpSubmersible sump pumps are more common than pedestal since they are typically installed when a house is built. This type of sump pump is submerged underwater in your sump pit. They come in waterproof containers to minimize the risk of damage and have a grate which prevents the flow of debris. Because they’re located in the sump basin, they help reduce space on your basement floor. A consequence of this is that they produce less noise since the motor is in the water.

Submersible pumps typically offer more power than pedestal sump pumps which means they can pump water faster, making them the most effective solution. This also makes them the best choice for emergencies such as flooding. The possibility to have a backup battery makes this a particularly reliable choice particularly when the power goes out. So many advantages come at a cost and submersible sump pumps tend to be more expensive from the initial purchase to the cost of repairs. They’re also more difficult to access when repairs are required. Despite this, they’re probably the best option of the two.

  • More expensive
  • Harder to access


a pedestal sump pump

Generally a less expensive option, pedestal sump pumps come in two pieces. There’s the standalone motor which sits on or above the basement floor and the hose/shaft which feeds into the sump pit. Because the motor is not in the water they do carry some risk of overheating so this is something to keep in mind before purchase. However, there’s obviously less chance of water damage since the motor is above ground. Due to their shape, pedestal sump pumps are generally best used for shallow or narrow sump pits. They’re nice and easy to repair since the motor is not in the pit itself. Unfortunately, pedestal sump pumps are not as powerful as submersible sump pumps and can obviously take up more basement space since they’re not fully inside the pit.

  • Less expensive
  • Easy to repair
  • Reduced risk of water damage
  • Chance of overheating
  • Not as powerful
  • Take up space

Things to consider

At the end of the day, you want your sump pump to do its primary job. But if you’re between several sump pumps and you’re not sure which to buy, finding one with particular features may help you decide. Here are a few things to consider for your sump pump in order to help you narrow down your options:

Switch: The type of switch that your sump pump has can have an effect on the longevity of the product. Much of this is down to the size of your sump pit. After all, you don’t want the switch-hitting the basin wall or any other obstruction. The main types of switches are tethered, vertical and electronic. Tethered switches provide longer run and rest times but require a larger sump pit. Vertical switches can operate in narrow sump pits but provide fewer rest times between cycles. Electronic switches don’t have moving parts so can’t get stuck. However, contaminants in the water can provide some interference which may mean cleaning the electronic probes on occasion.

Horsepower: Horsepower is very important because the more your sump pump has, the quicker it can shift water. More powerful sump pumps can cost a little more to run as they tend to use more electricity. But if they’re pumping out the water faster, this may well balance out. The amount of horsepower you need is really down to the area of drainage, the depth to the groundwater and the depth of the basement. The standard for most houses is a 1/3 hp pump. Remember, it’s better to opt for a sump pump with more horsepower and have too much than finding you don’t have enough.

Housing: If you want a sump pump that is durable and can perform well for a long time, you really need to take a look at the materials of the housing. If it’s durable then it shouldn’t rust, crack or break even with extended usage. Thermoplastic is typically the cheapest and lightest material and does not rust easily though it can be prone to cracking. Much like thermoplastic, stainless steel doesn’t rust a great deal though it is quite a heavy material in comparison. Cast iron is a nice balance between the two because it’s least likely to break and while heavier than thermoplastic, is lighter than stainless steel. It can rust but an epoxy coating can reduce this. Materials can play a big part in the overall price of the sump pump.


We think we’ve dealt with most of the main things to consider when buying a sump pump. But just in case, here is a handy FAQ section in case you still have any unanswered questions.

Should I buy a pedestal or submersible pump?
This really depends on your specific needs. Pedestal sump pumps tend to be more economical but if you need something quick and efficient a submersible pump is the way to go. But be aware that submersible pumps tend to be more expensive. The size of the sump pump pit can also dictate which is best for you.

How much horsepower should the sump pump have?
The more horsepower, the quicker the sump pump can move water. If only a small amount of water accumulates in the basin then a lower horsepower pump may well do the job. But for flooding emergencies go for something more powerful (this will probably be a submersible sump pump). You’ll have to make sure it will fit in the basin, though.

How big does the sump basin have to be?
Bigger is better with sump basins as pump cycles can then be longer. This means your sump pump is not constantly on and off, warming up and cooling down. This helps maintain its longevity. The size of the basin can have an impact on which type of sump pump you go for in terms of the pump switch. You don’t want that hitting the sides of the basin and breaking.

What material should the sump pump be made of?
Sump pumps can be made from various materials including cast iron, stainless steel, and thermoplastic to name a few. You want something that is strong and durable, allowing your sump pump to last a long time. If cost is an issue, thermoplastic sump pumps tend to be cheaper and are resistant to rust. Otherwise, go for something stronger such as cast iron or stainless steel.

Note: for some reason some readers land on this page looking for a hot water circulating pump, if that’s the case I’d recommend reading this guide.


Choosing a sump pump takes time. It’s a very important purchase to make as it can prevent costly damage and a lot of wasted time if you choose well. From deciding on a pedestal or submersible sump pump to choosing between those made of thermoplastic or cast iron, there’s plenty to think about.

With the right information, the journey of buying your sump pump becomes that little bit easier. Sump pumps have really advanced in recent years as each big brand tries to get ahead of the competition. The result is a wide range of sump pumps at an equally wide range of prices. So no matter your budget, there’s a great product out there for you.

We hope that our reviews of sump pumps and buying guide help you make your decision. Try not to delay your purchase too long as you never know when you’ll next need a sump pump. Next time an emergency strikes you’ll be prepared. Good luck!


Related buying guides:

About the Author Adam Harris

Hi there! My name is Adam and I write for HealthyHandyman. I have a great passion for writing about everything related to tools, home improvement, and DIY. In my spare time, I'm either fishing, playing the guitar, or spending quality time with my beloved wife. You'll also often find me in my workshop working on some new project!