Healthyhandyman is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

10 Best Tool Boxes for the Money in 2020 – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

man pulling Milwaukee Rolling Modular Tool Box

Even if you only work inside your workshop or garage, it’s common to need your tools in other places. For instance, you may need them for a repair in the home or when a vehicle is broken down and you don’t want to tow it.

A good toolbox does more than help you transport your tools though. It will also keep them organized so you can always find the tool you need without wasting time digging through the pile. Separate compartments help you organize everything and offer a way to group similar tools for easy access.

Whether you’ve got a collection of diverse power tools for professional work or just a few hand tools for basic home repairs, the perfect toolbox is somewhere on this list. To help you figure out which one it is, we’ve written up the following reviews about our favorites so they’re easy to compare.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites:

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
DEWALT DWST17806 Tstak Tool Box DEWALT DWST17806 Tstak Tool Box
  • Modular stacking system
  • Heavy-duty metal hinges and latches
  • Can design it to fit your needs
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Performance Tool W54012 Plastic Tool Box Performance Tool W54012 Plastic Tool Box
  • Removable tray for your most-used tools
  • Clear-top organizer for small items
  • Comes in various sizes
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Milwaukee Rolling Modular Tool Box Milwaukee Rolling Modular Tool Box
  • Three separate toolboxes that lock together
  • Metal reinforced corners and locks
  • Weather sealed
  • Stanley STST70574 Soft Sided Tool Bag Stanley STST70574 Soft Sided Tool Bag
  • 600 denier polyester construction
  • Durable but light
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Stalwart 75-2250 Rolling Tool Box Stalwart 75-2250 Rolling Tool Box
  • Wheels and handle make it easy to move
  • Cable hooks on the back for keeping an extension cord
  • Provides two tiers of tool storage
  • The 10 Best Tool Boxes – Reviews 2020:

    1. DEWALT DWST17806 Tstak Tool Box – Best Overall

    DEWALT DWST17806 Tstak Tool Box

    The Tstak toolbox from DEWALT is a modular system of stacking toolboxes that are all built to work together. There are 10 different modular components to the system, including deep toolboxes, drawers, and even some with wheels that the rest can stack on top of, making it easy to transport everything. Simply grab the boxes with the tools you need, stack them up, and set out.

    One great thing about DEWALT products is that you can always trust them to be built well, and this set of toolboxes is no exception. They’re made from thick, durable plastic that won’t rust or corrode with anti-rust metal latches to keep everything safe and secure. These are so sturdily constructed that they’re protected by a limited lifetime warranty.

    No matter what size of tools you need to store and transport, you’ll find an appropriately sized component in the Tstak system. The deep boxes will fit large power tools with no problems, and you can get smaller boxes for hand tools. Unfortunately, you’ll have to purchase each component separately, but that’s what allows you to build a custom setup that’s perfect for your needs.

    Pros
    • Modular stacking system
    • Can design it to fit your needs
    • Heavy-duty metal hinges and latches
    • The extra-large size will fit power tools with ease
    • Protected by a limited lifetime warranty
    Cons
    • Each component must be purchased separately

    2. Performance Tool Plastic Tool Box – Best Value

    Performance Tool W54012 Plastic Tool Box

    Not everyone who needs a toolbox is a professional looking for heavy-duty equipment. For the homeowner who just has a few tools to organize, the Performance Tool W54012 Plastic Toolbox is the right size and price. It’s one of the cheapest toolboxes we’ve tested, and while it’s not meant for carrying a heavy set of power tools, it’s ideal for organizing a small set of tools meant for odd jobs around the home.

    You can choose between four sizes, ranging from 12 inches to 19 inches in length. Inside, there’s a removable tray that you can keep your most-used tools in for easy access. On top, small dividers make it easy to store screws and other small hardware with a clear lid so you can tell where everything is at a glance.

    This toolbox is made entirely from plastic that won’t rust or corrode. It’s not the most durable toolbox on the market, but for the handy homeowner with a few tools to store, it’s probably the best toolbox for the money.

    Pros
    • Priced affordably
    • Removable tray for your most-used tools
    • Comes in various sizes
    • Clear-top organizer for small items
    • All-plastic construction won’t rust or corrode
    Cons
    • It’s not the most durable toolbox

    3. Milwaukee Rolling Modular Tool Box – Premium Choice

    Milwaukee Rolling Modular Tool Box

    Professionals on the go need a tool storage solution that’s strong and reliable with multiple storage compartments for storing tools of different types and sizes. We think that solution is this Rolling Modular Toolbox from Milwaukee. It’s one of the strongest, most reliable toolboxes we’ve seen, though it’s accompanied by a pretty hefty price tag as well.

    This modular tool storage system is completely stackable, making it easy to transport everything at once with the telescoping handle and built-in wheels. And thanks to the impressive weight capacity of 250 pounds, you can rest assured that your toolbox can handle the load.

    You’ll get three separate toolboxes with this setup, allowing you to organize your tools in whatever way suits you best. Each box is weather-sealed and has metal reinforced corners and locks to ensure your tools are always safe from everything, including theft and the weather. The whole set weighs 45 pounds, which would be heavy if you had to carry it, but isn’t bad since it rolls.

    Pros
    • Impressive weight capacity of 250 pounds
    • Three separate toolboxes that lock together
    • Metal reinforced corners and locks
    • Weather sealed
    • Telescoping handle and wheels make it easy to transport
    Cons
    • Extremely expensive
    • Weighs 45 pounds

    4. Stanley STST70574 Soft Sided Tool Bag

    Stanley STST70574 Soft Sided Tool Bag

    This 12-inch tool bag from Stanley weighs less than a pound but will keep all your small tools neatly organized. It’s made from 600-denier polyester, making it durable and strong without adding extra weight. To that end, it’s protected by a limited lifetime warranty, so you can trust that this bag will be around to carry your tools for a long time.

    The vertical pouches on the inside and outside of this bag make it easy to locate whatever tool you’re looking for. Unfortunately, you’ll only be able to fit small tools inside since it’s not the most spacious tool tote we’ve tested.

    Pros
    • Pouches store tools vertically for easy locating
    • 600 denier polyester construction
    • Durable but light
    • Limited lifetime warranty
    Cons
    • Only suitable for small hand tools

    5. Stalwart 75-2250 Rolling Tool Box

    Stalwart 75-2250 Rolling Tool Box

    When you have quite a few tools to store and they need to be portable, this rolling toolbox from Stalwart will fit them, though its cheap construction leaves some doubt about how long it will be there to serve you. Still, it’s got some great features like the built-in cable hooks for neatly storing extension cords.

    This toolbox features two crates that lock together, providing ample room for a large number of tools. The bottom portion is deep and wide open for your large power tools and the top has multiple compartments and organizers to keep your smaller tools in order. Unfortunately, it’s a bit more expensive than other options, despite the cheap quality of the materials used.

    Pros
    • Wheels and handle make it easy to move
    • Provides two tiers of tool storage
    • Cable hooks on the back for keeping an extension cord
    Cons
    • More expensive than other options
    • Cheaply constructed

    6. Allied Tools 38231 Metal Tool Box

    Allied Tools 38231 Metal Tool Box

    At 17 inches long, this metal toolbox from Allied Tools is perfect for storing a set of small tools for household repairs. It’s durably built and more spacious than you might expect. But it’s the ocean blue paint job that will attract many to this toolbox. It’s an attractive look, though you’re paying a premium for the hue. Disappointingly, there are two large stickers on this toolbox that left behind a residue that was extremely hard to remove.

    This toolbox weighs nearly eight pounds. That’s not a lot on its own, but once it’s filled with tools, it might be a bit hefty to store on the top shelf of the closet. But it is very secure, with latches that can each be separately padlocked.

    Pros
    • All-metal construction keeps tools well protected
    • Covered by a limited lifetime warranty
    • Each latch can be padlocked
    Cons
    • It’s pretty heavy due to metal construction
    • Two large stickers don’t want to come off

    7. GEARWRENCH 83151 Steel Tool Box

    GEARWRENCH 83151 Steel Tool Box

    Toolboxes come in all sorts of designs, such as this three-drawer steel toolbox from GEARWRENCH. All three drawers pull out to the front and there’s even access from the flip-up top. Unfortunately, there’s no tray in the top, so it’s not nearly as useful as it could be.

    To keep your tools safe and secure, there’s a lock at the top, allowing you to use the included key to lock your tools down. The black powder coating looks great and works to prevent corrosion and rust from ruining your nice toolbox.

    The drawers glide smoothly on ball-bearing slides. Too bad you can’t fit anything large inside. While this toolbox is perfect for storing screwdrivers, sockets, and other small items, that’s about all you can fit inside. Overall, this is a nice toolbox, but it doesn’t provide quite enough functionality for the high price.

    Pros
    • 3 sliding drawers with top access
    • Ball-bearing drawer slides
    • Lock it all down by key
    • Black powder-coated to prevent corrosion and rust
    Cons
    • It’s one of the more expensive options
    • Can’t fit any large tools inside
    • No tray for the top portion

    8. WORKPRO 17-inch Plastic Tool Box

    WORKPRO 17-inch Plastic Tool Box

    This WORKPRO plastic toolbox is 17 inches long and just shy of 10 inches wide. It’s a two-tiered design with a top half that slides back to allow access to the bottom. Altogether, it’s just 5.5 inches deep, so don’t expect to fit anything but hardware, fasteners, and other little items inside.

    But if that’s what you need to store, this toolbox is perfect. It’s got 18 total compartments and they’re adjustable so you can set everything up however you prefer. You’ll even be able to see a lot of it without opening the box thanks to the clear lid. The whole thing is plastic, except for the latches that pull the top and bottom out of alignment when closed. This caused the plastic on ours to crack, so it’s safe to say that durability is not a strong point with this product.

    Pros
    • Compartments are adjustable
    • 18 total compartments
    • Transparent lid allows you to see everything before you open
    Cons
    • Meant for very small tools like sockets and bits
    • Latches force the top and bottom to come out of alignment
    • The plastic isn’t strong and ours cracked

    9. Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Toolbox

    Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Toolbox

    Affordably priced and utterly basic, the Akro-Mils ProBox Plastic Toolbox is a poorly designed tote made from questionable materials. We’ve had great luck with plenty of plastic toolboxes, but this one is made of weak, thin plastic that’s flimsy and far from durable. Even the metal latch isn’t much better since it fell off the toolbox during regular use.

    However, it’s the removable tray that really holds this toolbox back. We love a good removable tray, making it easy to access the tools you use most. But this one has a giant hole in the middle that causes everything to fall into the main compartment, defeating the point of even having the tray in the first place.

    Pros
    • The price is affordable
    Cons
    • The metal latch fell off
    • Tools fall through the hole in the top tray
    • Made out of weak plastic

    10. BLACK+DECKER Tool Box

    BLACK+DECKER BDST60096AEV Tool Box

    There are a lot of BLACK+DECKER tools that we like, but the BDST60096AEV toolbox isn’t one of them. It’s made from cheap plastic that feels flimsy and left us doubting its quality. Despite this, it’s more expensive than other toolboxes that are built stronger. After using it, we wouldn’t trust this toolbox enough to carry it while it’s full.

    We did like the 10 compartments that make it easy to organize your small tools. But once the latch fell off when we tried to latch it down, we realized that this toolbox didn’t offer enough to keep testing it. The last thing we want is for the latch to fall off while we’re carrying it, dumping our expensive tools all over the ground.

    Pros
    • Has 10 compartments to organize your tools
    Cons
    • Thin and flimsy
    • Not sturdy enough to carry heavy tools
    • Overpriced for the quality
    • The latch falls off at random

    Buyer’s Guide

    While all of these products are built to perform the same basic function, differences between them mean that each is best suited for a particular situation. For example, you wouldn’t want to get a 12-inch long canvas tool bag for carrying all of your power tools like drills, impact drivers, and sawzalls. Instead, you’d be better served by a large plastic toolbox with a telescoping handle and wheels that make it much easier to transport all of those heavy tools.

    This short buyer’s guide is meant to help you figure out exactly what type of toolbox you need. From canvas tool bags to metal toolboxes, there’s a perfect tool tote for your collection somewhere, and we aim to help you find it.

    Toolbag vs Toolbox

    The first decision we’ll get out of the way is whether you need a toolbox or a tool bag. They both hold tools, but that’s about the end of the similarities between them.

    Toolbag

    These are the best choice when you have just a few tools to store or your collection consists almost entirely of small hand tools. These are often the preferred choice for electricians since they use mainly small tools. Likewise, these are a great choice for the handy homeowner who has a small collection of basic tools for making repairs around the house. The side pockets on the interior and exterior of a tool bag are set vertically, which stands up your tools, making them much easier and quicker to locate.

    When empty, a tool bag folds flat so it doesn’t take up space. Even with tools inside, the tool bag will only take up slightly more space than the tools themselves. And since they’re usually made from thick canvas, they’re durable enough to hold up without adding any extra weight. The handles are usually softer and more comfortable than a toolbox and shoulder straps are also common.

    On the other hand, you can’t fit as much in a tool bag. They’re also not a great choice for large tools like power tools that need lots of space and weigh quite a bit. Carrying a canvas bag full of heavy power tools would be a lot of work. Also, although a tool bag is more space-conscious than a single toolbox, if you need several, toolboxes are a better choice because they stack, saving you storage space.

    Pros
    • Takes up less space
    • Vertical pockets make it easier to locate your tools
    • Very lightweight
    • Handles are comfortable to hold
    • Often includes a shoulder strap
    Cons
    • Doesn’t carry as much
    • Not a great choice for heavy and large tools
    • They aren’t stackable

    Toolbox

    When you have a large tool collection or just large tools, toolboxes tend to be the better option. They’re generally larger and stronger so they can fit tools like circular saws and hammer drills. If you need to fill more than one toolbox, they’ll save you a good deal of space by stacking on top of each other. They don’t all stack though, so it’s a feature you’ll need to look for if it’s important to you.

    Many of the larger toolboxes feature wheels and telescoping handles so you can more easily transport those cumbersome tool collections. They also have multiple compartments that make it easier to organize your tools by type or size.

    On the flip side, it can be harder to locate your tools with them all piled on top of each other, even if they’re in separate compartments. Plus, toolboxes are usually made from plastic or metal, which tends to be a good deal heavier than canvas. Finally, a toolbox is always one size, regardless of whether it’s full, empty, or anywhere between.

    Pros
    • Are often stackable to save space
    • Come in large sizes great for big tools
    • Often have wheels and telescoping handles
    • Multiple compartments make it easy to organize
    Cons
    • InsertConsHere

    divider 4

    Picking the Right Toolbox

    For those who have many big tools or just a big tool collection, a toolbox is often the best type of tool storage system. But there are loads of different toolboxes that come in various sizes, designs, layouts, and materials. In this section, we’re going to take a look at some of the decisions you’ll need to make and help clarify the pros and cons of each choice.

    Materials

    First, you’ll need to decide if you want a metal or a plastic toolbox, as these are the most commonly used materials for toolboxes today. Let’s take a look at some of the benefits and drawbacks to each.

    Plastic

    Plastic toolboxes tend to be lightweight and they come in many different sizes. Generally speaking, plastic toolboxes aren’t as durable as metal ones. That doesn’t mean that a plastic toolbox is automatically weak though. Many of these are very robust, but some cheap ones are made from flimsy, thin plastic that isn’t sturdy enough for professional use. That said, we’ve seen plastic toolboxes with weight capacities of up to 250 pounds.

    But plastic toolboxes are more durable than metal in one sense; they don’t rust or corrode. And speaking of weather, they won’t absorb heat from the sun like metal either, so you’re less likely to burn yourself when you’re working in the hot summer sun.

    Another thing to consider is the safety of your tools. If you have a large plastic toolbox, it might be difficult to run away with, but it’s probably not that hard to break into.

    Pros
    • Lightweight
    • Won’t corrode or rust
    • Won’t absorb heat from the sun
    Cons
    • Not as strong and durable as metal
    • Your tools aren’t as secure

    Metal

    Naturally, a metal toolbox is going to be more durable than a plastic one, except for when it comes to corrosion since metal is susceptible to rusting. On a similar note, if you work outside, be careful picking up a metal toolbox after it has been sitting in the hot sun.

    If you’re carrying your toolbox by hand, then the extra weight of a metal toolbox might get to be a nuisance. However, the extra security might be a blessing since it’s much harder to break into a metal toolbox than a plastic one. Of course, if your toolbox is small enough to walk away with, this won’t make much of a difference.

    Pros
    • Durable and robust
    • Keeps your tools more secure
    Cons
    • Might rust or corrode
    • Heavier than plastic
    • Gets very hot in the sun

    Size

    Every person will need toolboxes of a different size, based on the size of their tool collection. If you only have a few small hand tools, then a three-tiered rolling tool chest would be overkill. On the other hand, if you have the entire range of DeWalt power tools and you want it to be safely stored in a portable toolbox, then a handheld 12-inch plastic toolbox isn’t the right choice.

    Determine how much tool storage you realistically need, then pick a toolbox to match that.

    Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Toolbox on the table

    Portability

    If you mainly work inside your home, garage, or workshop, then portability might not be high up on your list of priorities. But if you’re a professional handyman who’s in and out of different homes with your toolkit all the time, portability is going to be an important factor to consider.

    Naturally, small toolboxes are easily portable, but they won’t store your large tools, so that’s not what we’re talking about. Instead, you should consider things like wheels and handles that let you easily pull your tools along behind you rather than carrying all that weight.

    Stackability

    In the same vein, stacking toolboxes can save you from making multiple trips to the truck, ultimately saving you time. Stacking the toolboxes on top of each other not only makes them easier to transport, but it also saves loads of space in your work truck or garage.

    Extra Features

    We’ve covered several of the most important features that you need to be considering when looking for a toolbox, but that’s not the entire list. The following are some extra features that are worth giving some thought to since they can make your life just a little bit easier.

    • Divided organizers
    • Removable tray for your most commonly used tools
    • Clear lids to easily see your small items
    • Weather sealing
    • Locking latches for security

    Questions to Ask Yourself

    We’ve gone over a lot of information, but it all applies to each person differently. If you’re having trouble figuring out which of these features you need to prioritize, try asking yourself the following questions to really clarify your priorities.

    • What tools are you storing?
    • How many tools do you need to store?
    • Do you require separate compartments for different types of tools?
    • Do you need mobility?
    • Would you like small pockets or organizers for hand tools and hardware?
    • How much are you willing to spend on tool storage?

    divider 8

    Conclusion

    No tool collection is complete without a rugged and portable way to store, organize, and transport all of those tools. Over the years, we’ve been let down by quite a few toolboxes, but as you can tell from our reviews, we’ve found three that have earned our trust and our recommendations.

    Our top choice is the DEWALT TSTAK Toolbox. It’s a modular stacking system that lets you build precisely the toolbox you need, piece by piece. From deep chests with wheels to units with pullout drawers, each of these components stacks neatly on top of each other for easy transportation. Plus, they’re all protected by a limited lifetime warranty.

    For the homeowner with just a few tools looking for a budget way to store them, we suggest the Performance Tool W54012 Plastic Toolbox. This affordably priced toolbox is made from rust-proof plastic with a removable tray for easy access to your most commonly used tools.

    But if you’re a professional who needs top-quality toolboxes you can count on in any situation, you need the Milwaukee Packout Rolling Modular Toolbox with three weather-sealed stacking toolboxes featuring metal-reinforced corners and locks with a 250-pound weight capacity.

    Related posts

    Other categories

    Project ideas

    Hand & power tools

    woodworking

    Garden

    Automotive