Dremel Saw Max vs Ultra Saw: Which One’s Best?

Last Updated:

Image
The Winner (#1)
Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
The Runner-up (#2)
Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
Model
Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
User Rating
The Winner (#1)
Image
Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
Model
Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
User Rating
User Reviews
The Runner-up (#2)
Image
Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
Model
Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
User Rating
User Reviews

Are you looking to expand your DIY loadout with a small, circular saw for quick jobs and use in tight quarters? Perhaps you’re just getting started building your tool arsenal and want a capable, easy-to-use circular saw, but aren’t ready for a full-size model? Maybe you are short on space, so you want a saw that can perform multiple tasks and not take up a lot of room. Well, you are in the right review, because we are getting ready to compare two Dremel offerings that can satisfy all these situations and more.

The origins of the circular saw blade are something of a mystery. There are no clear records of who invented it, or when, although references occur as early as the 16th century. The first modern, hand-held tool appears to have been invented in 1923 by Edward Michel. In 1928, he changed the name of his company to SKILSAW, Inc. and that is why many people call these tools skill-saws.

Dremel’s Ultra-Saw and Saw-Max circular saws are scaled-down versions of the typical 7.25” saws, featuring 4” and 3” blades, respectively. Each is a capable saw in its own right, so which one do we call the best? If we tell you now, will you promise to read the entire review? Okay, we trust you. We recommend the Ultra-Saw for reasons we’ll lay out in the rest of the review.

Dremel US40 in use

What are the differences between them?

You are still reading, right? Excellent, we knew you didn’t have your fingers crossed. We like to pit a pair of tools against each other in specific categories and award points to the best performer. In the end, the tool with the most points wins.

Power – Point to the Ultra-Saw

You have to expect this result just from the names of the tools alone. “Ultra” is always stronger than “Max” in the world of anime, graphic novels, and comic books. That’s the case here, with the Ultra-Saw hitting your workbench with a 7.5 A motor versus the 6 A motor of the Saw-Max.

Dremel SM20 in use

Durability – Point to the Ultra-Saw

Dremel made changes in the materials it uses in the Ultra-Saw to increase its durability and expand the types of tasks it can tackle without damaging the tool. For example, the Ultra-Saw has a metal foot and guard that will resist the heat created in heavy metal grinding and cutting operations. There’s nothing worse than having parts of your tool melt while in use. Dremel has also improved the durability of the drive train, claiming three times more life than the Saw-Max.

Material cutting and finishing, type and capacity – Point to the Ultra-Saw

With all the design improvements and upgrades, Dremel has positioned the Ultra-Saw to take on more tasks on bigger stock. While both saws still cut the same materials, you can do more with the Ultra-Saw.

Dremel SM20 for wood

Ease of handling – Point to the Saw-Max

The Saw-Max is lighter at 1.7 pounds, compared to 2.1 pounds for the Ultra-Max. It is also slimmer. This can be an important difference for users with smaller hands and for extended one-handed use. Smaller may also be better for crafters with consistently smaller projects.

Price – Point to the Saw-Max

Does it always have to come down to money? That’s a rhetorical question, no need to answer. And, yes, it often does. You can buy a comparably equipped Saw-Max for less than an Ultra-Saw.

Quick Rundown of the Ultra-Saw:

Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
202 Customer Reviews
Dremel US40-01 Ultra-Saw Tool Kit with 4...
  • Powerful 7.5-Amp Motor for tough applications and faster cutting
  • 3-in-1 Tool for Expanded Versatility: Go beyond just cutting- with the added benefit of surface...
  • Faster Speed of Cut: Rip through plywood and cut more metal

Where does the US40 shine? (No, it doesn’t have a LED work light. That’s not the type of “shine” we are talking about in this case.)

Pros
  • More powerful 7.5 A motor
  • Handles larger material and additional tasks
  • More durable construction where it counts
Cons
  • More expensive of the two
  • Heavier and larger

Quick Rundown of the Saw-Max:

Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
710 Customer Reviews
Dremel SM20-02 120-Volt Saw-Max Tool Kit
  • Versatile cutting system for a variety of materials (wood, plastic, metal, tile, masonry)
  • Powerful 6-amp motor for tough applications
  • Worm drive gearing for durability and power

Guess what? The plusses and minuses of the Saw-Max are the inverses of those for the Ultra-Saw. No surprise there.

Pros
  • Less expensive
  • Smaller and lighter for easier handling
  • Cuts the same materials as the Ultra-Saw
Cons
  • Not as robust a tool; shouldn’t be used for certain jobs
  • Cuts smaller stock than the Ultra-Saw

What the Users Say

We know our tools and are here to help with your decision-making process, steering you to the best tool for your needs. Still, it is our practice to research what other users of the tools have to say about their close encounters with the tools in the review. Without further ado, let’s look at a few of those reactions.

Positive comments about the Ultra-Saw include mention of it being well made, powerful, and great on small jobs – just the types of reactions you hope to find when dealing with a tool from a company like Dremel.

Negative comments include the blades being expensive and burning up fast. The special size blade arbor limits users to Dremel blades.  Some people found that the metal guard or foot arrived from the factory cracked. The motor may get hot to the point of smoke and fail.

For the Saw-Max, positive comments include high praise from many female users about the tool’s small size and ease of use. It is frequently noted how great it is for small projects and for working on thin materials such as paneling and drywall. It does an excellent job removing dust when using the optional dust port adaptor.

Negatives for the Saw-Max are essentially the same as for the Ultra-Max, with the addition of reports of plastic components melting when grinding and cutting metal. Humm, where have we heard that before?

Popular Alternatives Worth Considering:

WORX WORXSAW 4-1/2" Compact Circular Saw –...
TACKLIFE Circular Saw with Metal Handle, 6...
WEN 36704 4.2-Amp 3-3/8-Inch Plunge Cut Compact...
WORX WORXSAW 4-1/2" Compact Circular Saw –...
TACKLIFE Circular Saw with Metal Handle, 6...
WEN 36704 4.2-Amp 3-3/8-Inch Plunge Cut Compact...
WORX WORXSAW 4-1/2" Compact Circular Saw –...
WORX WORXSAW 4-1/2" Compact Circular Saw –...
TACKLIFE Circular Saw with Metal Handle, 6...
TACKLIFE Circular Saw with Metal Handle, 6...
WEN 36704 4.2-Amp 3-3/8-Inch Plunge Cut Compact...
WEN 36704 4.2-Amp 3-3/8-Inch Plunge Cut Compact...

Conclusion

Dremel makes great tools, and both these saws will serve their intended purposes well. For lighter duty crafting and projects, you can get by with the Saw-Max, but we recommend spending a little more for the Ultra-Saw. It is a more robust tool, designed to handle more tasks, work on larger size material, and provide even more life. For the extra money, it is worth the added capabilities it puts in your hand.

Other Dremel posts we’ve published:
-> Best Dremels for Wood Carving 2019

-> Dremel 200 Series Rotary Tool Review

About the Author Adam Harris

Hi there! My name is Adam and I write for HealthyHandyman. I have a great passion for writing about everything related to tools, home improvement, and DIY. In my spare time, I'm either fishing, playing the guitar, or spending quality time with my beloved wife. You'll also often find me in my workshop working on some new project!