Ingersoll Rand 231C vs 231G: Which One’s Best?

  • December 7, 2018
Image
Best Choice
Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
Best Price
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
Model
Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
User Rating
User Reviews
650 Customer Reviews
35 Customer Reviews
Best Choice
Image
Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
Model
Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
User Rating
User Reviews
650 Customer Reviews
Best Price
Image
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
Model
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
User Rating
User Reviews
35 Customer Reviews

When it comes to loosening nuts on your vehicle, there is nothing better than a pneumatic impact wrench. Two of Ingersoll Rand’s better light models, the 231C and 231G, are pretty similar. In fact, they’re based on the same design. They’re both excellent impact wrenches that are durable and affordable. The right one for you is really a matter of personal taste, based on the differences as we define them.

Ingersoll Rand 231C in use

What’s the difference between them?

Performance – Edge: 231C

When it comes to the wrench itself, better performance is a matter of numbers. The 231G can deliver a maximum of 500 foot-pounds. The 231C can deliver a maximum of 600 foot-pounds. Truth be told, that is more than enough to do most of the work you will ever need from an impact wrench in your home garage working on normal vehicles. But if you have nuts that are badly corroded and seized up, you might need the extra torque to get them loose.

Price – Slight edge: 231G

Giving an edge on price in the day of Internet shopping can be something of a crapshoot. What seems cheapest today might tomorrow be a little more expensive, and you might find a deal somewhere that makes it on another day an absolute steal. Still, on your typical day absent a great sale somewhere, the 231G is a little cheaper. It’s a slight edge because at the price we’re talking it really shouldn’t make any difference. Still, if you’re counting pennies…

Ingersoll Rand 231G

Features – No edge

Although we’re a fan of the 231C’s extra power, when it comes to features above and beyond that, there really isn’t an edge that either holds. Both are well constructed and are durable. Both are comfortable to use. Neither comes with any real flashy extras that make us stand up and holler to the hills. Both are just very dependable, powerful pneumatic impact wrenches that get the job done.

Design – Edge: 231C

The 231C is a little smaller and a little lighter, which means it delivers better torque in a smaller frame. That’s a fairly impressive feat in its own right. When it comes to a comparative analysis between it and its similar cousin the 231G, it gives the 231C a definite edge.

Quick Rundown of Ingersoll Rand 231C:

Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
650 Customer Reviews
Ingersoll Rand 231C Super-Duty Air Impact Wrench,...
  • Classic, reliable design offers proven power, performance, and durability
  • Twin-hammer mechanism delivers a maximum torque of 600 foot-pounds
  • Adjustable power regulator provides easy control of torque output

A lot of muscle for not a lot of money on a frame small enough to hold in your hand. That just about summarizes Ingersoll Rand’s 231C perfectly.

Pros
  • More powerful
  • Very durable
Cons
  • Little more expensive

Quick Rundown of Ingersoll Rand 231G:

Sale
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
35 Customer Reviews
Ingersoll Rand 231G Edge Series 1/2-Inch Air...
  • Exclusive twin hammer impact mechanism
  • Variable-speed trigger
  • Ergonomic grip

A little cheaper than the 231C, the 231G doesn’t sacrifice so much power that it can’t do almost anything you’ll want it to do in the home garage.

Pros
  • Cheaper
  • Powerful
Cons
  • Not as powerful as the 231C

Conclusion

Either of these tools will do a great job in your home auto mechanic inventory. They are both powerful enough to do most tasks you set them to, and are small and portable enough to be portable within the framework of being tied to an air compressor. We liked the power of the 231C a bit more, and although it’s more than you probably need to swap out the lug nuts on the family car, if those lug nuts are rusted in place the extra oomph might come in handy. But if you want to get the work done for a few bucks less, the 231G is a very able alternative. The choice of which one is better is best answered that way, do you want extra power or to save a couple of bucks.

About the Author Adam Harris

Hi there! My name is Adam and I write for HealthyHandyman. I have a great passion for writing about everything related to tools, home improvement, and DIY. In my spare time, I'm either fishing, playing the guitar, or spending quality time with my beloved wife. You'll also often find me in my workshop working on some new project!